|
IT benchmarking is a strategic management method
which compares IT services of various
companies.
Performance is compared in terms of efficiency and effectiveness. Comparisons
can be made on a broader scale including cross-industry basis.
The objective of IT benchmarking is to identify potential optimization and performance
enhancing methods. The benchmark known as the 'best practice' is the company which
meets most of the defined efficiency
and effectiveness requirements.
Benchmarking can be used by businesses to stay updated in terms
of ICT expenditure and to address strategic issues such
as outsourcing. Many
decisions to outsource are made due to lack of understanding the potential of company ICT departments to
deliver services under appropriate circumstances.
Persia Telecom benchmarking methods have enabled corporate leaders to recognize
the impact of their ICT investments have on business performance and whether their
investments and performance is above and below
industry average. These methods also enabled company management to compare
their ICT decisions with competitors and
other organizations.

Persia Telecom realized under-investments in the ICT field across the Middle East
and poor performances by ICT departments in meeting customer requirements and corporate
goals. This was a result of poor investments rather than lack of expertise and enthusiasm. Our benchmarking methods can be used to overcome historically
poor relations between IT departments and customers and open the communications process which leads to
improved alignments with user needs and understanding of IT services.
Benchmarking can provide a common platform for ICT and business management to meet and make
positive decisions on resource allocation for gaining strategic advantages.
Persia Telecom suggests companies
to answer the following questions to measure the
alignment between businesses and their strategies:
-
Does the IT department
understand and support the business model and strategy?
-
Are your IT
investments appropriately aligned with business
objectives?
-
Is the IT department improving
and
managing capabilities required to deliver
values to the company?
-
Is your IT
performance sufficient in enabling continuous
alignment?
After responding to these requirements, our customers
should consider the following issues to improve
their strategic alignment:
-
Understanding business
strategy
-
Establishing organizational
objectives
-
Determining the best
fit
-
Assessing alignment
This
procedure provides companies with a unique
perspective of how well the business regards its
current information capabilities along a number of axes in particular:
-
Management value which indicates to what
extent the information systems support the
business functions from a
management perspective.
-
Importance
/ performance (of standard data sets)
-
Technical quality which indicates to what
extent the systems are technically sound, in
terms of their quality, reliability
and ease of operation.
-
Scale and annual costs of IT systems
Customer satisfaction including customer
perception of IT department services, its
ability to provide new functionality,
correct and accurate data, availability of
services, responsiveness and user support.
Advantages of IT benchmarking
From an economic point of view, IT benchmarking
replaces the market which is often subjected to an
obligation to conclude a contract or does not exist
due to lack of comparable services. Benchmarking
therefore supports pricing and improves the
efficiency of services which is not directly
subjected to market mechanisms.

Disadvantages of IT benchmarking
In many
cases, a significant amount of costs (overhead) is
allocated to individual IT services by using a
special key. If the applied key is not in accordance
with the cause of cost, the applied service-costs
are faulty and lead to a poor comparability. A
comparison is only valid when the scope of the
individual IT service has clear boundaries and is
respected by all parties correspondingly.
Typical Procedure
-
Identifying
efficiency and effectiveness criteria which
serve as comparative factors.
-
Finding (internal)
benchmarking partners and (external)
partners/donors, in order to set up a
comparative platform.
-
Setting up a key
data system by taking the comparability into
account.
-
Analyzing the
database and identifying the best-practice
participants. Definition of the so-called
“target benchmark”
-
Identifying
optimization potentials and guidelines by
comparison with the best practice.
-
Calculating
theoretical savings potentials (gap to
benchmark).
-
Extrapolating
objectives in order to close the gap to best
practice.
-
Setting up an
implementation plan
-
Controlling results
and improvements.
Structure
The
comparability plays an important role within IT
benchmarking. As standard IT services do not exist
on an inter-corporate basis, general IT functions
that exist in every company can help to make
comparison.
Usually, IT costs are divided according to function
and cost category, e.g.:
IT costs per IT units
-
Software
development (new unit)
-
Application
maintenance/support
-
Setting up an IT
infrastructure (mainframe/server)
-
Establishing IT
infrastructure ( PC/LAN)
-
Other IT
costs.
Type of IT
costs
-
Costs for IT staff
(including personnel-related costs)
-
Costs for external
IT consultants
-
Costs for hardware
-
Costs for software
-
Costs for IT
projects outsourcing
-
Costs for data
communication (Tel/Internet/Fax/…)
-
Other IT
costs.
How does Persia Telecom guarantee the
alignment success?
During all
phases and process improvements, we consult our customers with proven delivery methods and
step by step assistance including:
-
Performance
Benchmarking: providing quick performance
comparison against similar-sized companies or
industries
-
Risk Management of
“IT Governance”: facilitating IT risk assessment
and audit engagement
-
Result-Based
consulting: guiding and implementing IT process
improvement
|